The existing structure was built in 1949 in a residential neighborhood in Indianapolis, Indiana.  As the church grew, it expanded its facilities, adding offices, classrooms, and parking to the north.  This meant that the original main entrance, which faced south, was seldom used.  For this renovation in 2007, the architect's design turned the nave 180 degrees in order to create a larger worship space and connect both old and new facilities to the nave. This has created an entrance to the worship space that is welcoming and convenient to the rest of the campus. The renovation also added parish facilities and classrooms, as well as a cloister and courtyard. 

 

A primary consideration in the design of the expanded worship space was the placement of a new custom hand-crafted organ, which was being built for St. Paul's at the same time the renovation was underway.  The previous organ's location in chambers on the sides of the chancel was considered to be detrimental to its sound; it was determined that the new organ and musical ensembles would be located on the central axis of the nave. 

 

A new bell tower that rises above the surrounding neighborhood and serves as an entry to the growing church campus is part of the design. 

 

Silver Creek Engineering designed all structural systems for the project, including the modified worship area, the addition that will house education and social facilities, and the bell tower.  Silver Creek also performed the site design for the project, which included the integration of a former city street into the proposed church campus.
 

On November 16, 2007, the St. Paul's renovation was topped off, literally, with the placement of a 60 foot copper steeple.  A crowd of church members, neighbors, and media crews gathered to watch as a crane placed the steeple on top of the new belltower just before sunset.